Overview

Jim Mack's ICE Cream, nestled at 5745 Lincoln Hwy in York, PA, stands as a charming escape for ice cream lovers and families alike. This quaint, mom-and-pop ice cream shop carries a nostalgic aura that echoes through its retro building, drawing in both longtime locals and new visitors eager to taste quality frozen treats.

Their ice cream is the star attraction—creamy, smooth, and subtly flavored without the artificial aftertaste common in many commercial brands. Customers consistently praise the authentic, rich texture and well-balanced taste that sets Jim Mack's apart from typical grocery store options. This focus on quality speaks volumes about their commitment to the craft, making it a standout choice for anyone seeking a genuine ice cream experience.

Beyond just the ice cream, the atmosphere enhances the visit. W C captures the essence well, highlighting the old-school vibe that invites memories and family traditions. The place feels welcoming, a spot where parents pass down stories and children create new memories, making it perfect for families and those longing for a step back in time.

Service is another winning aspect. Whether grabbing ice cream to enjoy on site or calling ahead for takeout, customers report timely, friendly interaction without hassle. A notable moment shared by George Sheldon reflects their thoughtful customer care when they replaced a dropped cone without hesitation—a simple gesture that reveals the warmth behind the counters.

Jim Mack's ICE Cream is not just about a treat; it is about an experience. The location is easily accessible, making it a convenient stop for locals and visitors cruising through York. Its blend of quality, atmosphere, and personable service targets a broad audience—from nostalgic elders recalling their youth to families searching for an affordable, fun outing.

In essence, Jim Mack's ICE Cream offers more than just ice cream—it offers a slice of history, comfort, and community. If you're in the York area and craving a classic, well-crafted scoop surrounded by charm and friendly faces, this spot should be high on your list.


Amenities & Services

Popular for
Good for solo dining
Atmosphere
Casual

What Customers Say

Sandy Smith
Dec 11,2025
4/5
Called ahead for take out food. Grabbed ice cream when we stopped to pick up take out. No wait. Food was hot and good quality.
George Sheldon
Dec 11,2025
5/5
Love that place and I love their ice cream yesterday. We were there. I was trying to pay my ice cream cone fell off. They gave me another one free. I remember another Dairy Queen had to pay for mine, doing a good job. Jimmy Mack thumbs up
W C
Dec 11,2025
5/5
Cute little mom and pop ice cream shop! Love the old vibe about the place. My mother is always telling me when she was young and how her parents would take her here.
Michael Nace
Dec 11,2025
5/5
An excellent choice fo ice cream a fun place to take the family reasonably priced
Adorian Lazar
Dec 11,2025
5/5
One of the best and creamiest ice cream I've ever tasted. The flavor is subtle rather than overpowering, with none of the usual aftertaste found in chemically flavored grocery store ice cream! Loved the retro building that houses the business!
Valorie Reviews
Dec 11,2025
4/5
Definitely a spot I would come to more than once. Ice cream is cheap, within the $4 to $7 range dependent on what you get. They also had a lot of ice cream flavors to choose from. Not only does this place offer yummy ice-cream, but also a mini-golf course with about 20-25 holes. Not a super complicated course, so good for kids or a quick date. Cost was $7 a person. I did not have the opportunity to try the food, but it was available if it was something you are interested in. Can get pretty busy on a nice day, but has plenty of outdoor seating. My only wish is that this place accepted card. It is cash only, no cards accepted. However, there is an ATM available for use. I think switching to accepting cards and cash could be beneficial for the company and customers. Overall, a great place to go to if you are craving something sweet or looking for something to do. Will be returning.
Leonel Estrada
Dec 11,2025
5/5
Is very nice!! The ice cream store is not big itself but the area surrounding it is great! It has mini golf, a little arcade "house", it has basketball area with many basketball hopp sizes for the kiddos. Loved the mini golf area, very nice while you eat your delicious ice cream... The only "bad" thing for the ice cream is that they only accept cash, so no card... Great flavors. My kids like this place and they have fun in here so that all it matter for me, oh, and the ice cream for sure!!

Leave a Review

Location

Opening Hours

Monday 09:30 AM - 11:00 PM
Tuesday 09:30 AM - 11:00 PM
Wednesday 09:30 AM - 11:00 PM
Thursday 09:30 AM - 11:00 PM
Friday 09:30 AM - 11:00 PM
Saturday 09:30 AM - 11:00 PM
Sunday 09:30 AM - 11:00 PM
Top Picks for You

More Ice Cream Shops in York, Pennsylvania, USA

Handpicked spots for food lovers. Your next favorite meal awaits!